Chapters

The Illusions: Maya

Understand maya, two kinds of illusion, and how Self-realisation reveals Brahman behind the world's names and forms.

On this page

Questions about how the world began seem simple. But they assume that the things we want to explain already existed. Time, space and causation belong to the world. We cannot place them outside the world to explain its beginning.

  • When asks at what time the world began. But asking when time began assumes that time existed before its own beginning.
  • Whence asks where the world came from. But asking where space began assumes that another space surrounded it.
  • Wherefore asks why the world exists. But asking what caused causation assumes that causes existed before causation began.

Time stretches endlessly backward and forward, space has no boundaries, and the chain of causes has no apparent beginning or end. The intellect cannot get outside time, space and causation to explain where they came from. A dreamer has the same problem within a dream. Waking ends both the dreamer’s questions and the dream-world that raised them. Self-realisation brings a similar awakening from the confusion of the waking world.

World, an Illusion

The waking world follows time, space and causation more precisely than the dream-world does. Yet people experiencing either world believe it is real. Vedanta says the two differ only in degree, not in kind. Both are experiences shaped by time, space and causation, in which a world appears upon Brahman.

Maya is the name for the world’s reality, which cannot be described as either real or unreal. Its parts, ma and ya, mean not that. Each attempt to describe the world receives this answer:

  • Real: The world cannot be real because it does not last forever. It disappears in deep-sleep and dissolves upon Self-realisation.
  • Unreal: The world cannot be unreal either. Something unreal, like a man’s horns, never exists. But we experience the world now.
  • Partly real and partly unreal: This description also fails because reality and unreality cannot exist together.

A dreamer claims to be forty years old. University records, his school principal and his registered birth all support his account of his past. He believes the dream’s sun, hills and rivers have existed for ages. Yet the whole dream has lasted only four minutes. A fifty-year-old waker gives similar evidence for his own world. Each trusts his world and rejects the other’s. Evidence found within an experience does not prove that the experience is absolutely real.

A hypnotised person sees a lake in his lounge that nobody else sees. When the hypnosis ends, the lake disappears. Similarly, a person who does not know the supreme Self mistakes the body, mind and intellect for who he is. Because of this mistake, he experiences an imaginary world. Self-realisation ends this self-hypnosis and reveals Reality.

Intrinsic and Extrinsic Illusions

When we see shoes, dresses and pots made by craftspeople, we may assume that God made the world in the same way. Parthasarathy rejects this reasoning because it treats God as separate from the world. It also gives desires to an all-pervading Being. Instead, he recommends study, reflection and meditation to investigate the illusions that hide the Self.

Two kinds of illusion explain how we can fail to recognise something while seeing its properties elsewhere:

  • Intrinsic illusion: A person does not see the real object and its mistaken appearance together. Once the person recognises the object, the illusion disappears.
  • Extrinsic illusion: The object, its image and whatever produces the image all appear together.

A child mistakes a post in the dark for a ghost. The child sees the ghost, not the post. When someone brings a light, the child recognises the post and the ghost disappears. This is intrinsic illusion.

A mirror shows extrinsic illusion. You, your reflected image and the mirror producing it are all present together.

The rope-and-snake analogy combines both kinds. A boy steps on a rope in the dark and mistakes it for a snake. Seeing the snake instead of the rope is intrinsic illusion. But he describes the snake as six feet long, four inches thick and black. These are exactly the rope’s properties. The imagined snake reflects those properties, so it is also the means through which they appear. This is the extrinsic part of the same illusion.

How the Two Illusions Conceal Brahman

The world we experience follows the same pattern as the rope and snake. Seeing the world instead of Brahman is intrinsic illusion. Brahman alone exists. But because we do not know the Self, we see Brahman as separate things and beings.

At the same time, the world reflects Brahman’s properties. Brahman is eternal, all-pervading and infinite. Similarly, the world seems endless in time and boundless in space, with an infinite chain of causes. The world itself is the means through which these properties appear. This is extrinsic illusion.

The removal of these two illusions marks two stages of realisation:

  • Savikalpa samadhi: Partial realisation removes the extrinsic illusion. The seeker recognises Divinity in every being, whether sinner or saint. But the seeker still sees himself as separate from the God he recognises everywhere. So the intrinsic illusion remains.
  • Nirvikalpa samadhi: Total realisation removes the intrinsic illusion too. The seeker’s individuality merges with Divinity. This means there is no longer any separation between the person recognising God and God.

Recognising God throughout the world therefore brings the seeker closer to Reality. Complete Self-realisation ends the separation that remains between oneself and God.

World is God

The world is Brahman appearing through names and forms. It is not a separate product made by a separate creator. Things arranged in a new way can have properties different from those of their parts.

Four right-angled triangles form a square when their vertices meet at a point. Each triangle has two acute angles and a right angle. Its hypotenuse is longer than its other sides. The square, however, has four right angles and equal sides. Arranging the triangles this way creates a new form with different properties.

Two hydrogen atoms combine with one oxygen atom to form water. Hydrogen burns, and oxygen supports burning. But together they produce a liquid that puts out fire. The liquid has different properties from those of the gases.

Charcoal and diamond are both carbon. Yet charcoal is black, dull, soft and cheap, while diamond is brilliant, hard and precious. They differ because their carbon atoms are arranged differently.

All these examples show how different arrangements can produce different properties. They help explain the relation between Brahman and the world. Brahman is eternal and infinite, while the world’s forms are temporary and limited. They seem to be opposites because of their different names, forms and arrangements. The difference does not mean that a second reality exists independently of Brahman.

Why Heed an Illusion

If the world is an illusion, Vedanta’s teaching belongs to that illusion too. How, then, can it free anyone from the illusion?

Svapna simha vat, meaning like a dream-lion, gives the answer. A dreamer encounters a lion that pounces on him. Terrified, he jumps out of bed and wakes. The lion was imaginary, but its attack ended the whole dream. The lion disappeared along with everything else in the dream.

Vedantic knowledge does the same in waking experience. Although it belongs to the world we experience, it leads beyond that world to God-consciousness. Because it brings about spiritual awakening, it dissolves both the larger illusion and itself.