Strength of Emotion

Emotion helps us live well when we care beyond ourselves and let clear judgement guide what we do.

Vedanta aims to strengthen emotion by making it less selfish and helping it include others. It does not ask people to become cold or indifferent. Clear thinking helps feelings support a good life without taking control of it.

Emotion can overwhelm judgement. Parthasarathy points to Shakespeare’s King Lear, Othello and Macbeth to show the damage this can cause. Passion and sentiment belong in life, but giving in to them can harm both everyday life and spiritual wellbeing.

Let emotion remain part of life, but let the discerning intellect guide what you do. You can care for others and still judge clearly what needs to be done.

Oliver Goldsmith’s The Village Preacher gives an image of this balance. The preacher loves his neighbours and feels sympathy for them, but his thinking remains steady. He resembles a tall cliff rising above storm clouds. The clouds represent emotion, while the peak represents the intellect. The image shows that he feels deeply without letting his feelings disturb his judgement.

Arjuna lost this balance. Emotion overwhelmed him, so he laid down his weapons and refused to do his duty as a warrior. Krishna’s teaching in the Bhagavad Gita cleared his confusion and helped him act again.

Facets of Emotion

The quality of an emotion depends on whose interests it serves. Feeling that concerns only personal advantage is selfish. It becomes nobler when it includes the community’s welfare. Feeling that includes the whole universe, without favouring anyone, is divine.

Emotion resembles medicine. The right dose can heal, but too much can harm or kill. In the same way, feeling becomes dangerous when it focuses entirely on selfish interests. Its value depends on whom it concerns and how a person expresses it.

Love

Universal love includes fellow beings as naturally as we care for the different parts of our own body. We give attention to fingers, toes, eyes and ears because they all belong to one whole. We can extend that same sense of belonging to the world.

Attachment to one person can make us care less about others. A young man absorbed in his beloved may begin to see his parents, siblings and everyone else as burdens. Because his affection excludes others, he becomes indifferent or hostile towards them. A child shows the opposite kind of affection: it does not calculate whom to favour, so people feel drawn to it.

Attachment also makes our peace depend on what happens outside us. Parents worry constantly about their children. Wet feet on a valued carpet cause distress, and a dent in a cherished car feels like a personal injury. These events disturb the mind because attachment makes each one feel personal.

A partner or child may first help us understand affection. But that feeling need not stay within the family. It can extend to other people, creatures and nature. A spiritual person still meets responsibilities at home and in society, while caring about people beyond that small circle.

Kindness

Kindness is essential to spiritual growth. Ella Wheeler Wilcox’s verse places kindness above adding more gods, creeds and religious paths. Religious observance misses its purpose if it does not help people become compassionate.

But kindness must take account of what an action will lead to. Ahimsa means non-injury. If people take this to mean that they must never cause injury, they may let wrongdoing continue, even when their refusal leads to later harm. Parthasarathy criticises this interpretation in India, arguing that it left Hindus vulnerable to oppression and invasion. His reading of Shakespeare’s Hamlet also shows that a harsh action does not necessarily come from an unkind intention.

Arjuna makes this mistake when he refuses to fight his relatives. Krishna turns his concern towards restoring righteousness and protecting the people. In those circumstances, fighting serves the wider good.

Pity

Pity can make someone act out of sorrow instead of judgement. A person may keep trying to please others because disappointing them feels cruel. This can leave the person tormenting themselves rather than responding properly to others’ needs.

Sympathy therefore needs guidance. When you encounter suffering, the intellect must judge the situation before you decide what to do. Parthasarathy explains this through the law of karma: a person’s actions determine what happens to them. He expresses this as “You reap what you sow” and “You get what you deserve, not what you desire”. In his view, pity must take this link between actions and consequences into account. Feeling sorry for someone or wanting a different outcome cannot, by itself, tell you what the situation requires.

Charity

People can give wealth, service, affection or knowledge. Giving turns their attention towards another person’s welfare. Asking and taking keep their attention on personal wants that remain unmet, which disturbs their peace. Prayer becomes another way of expressing desire when it only asks for wealth, health, success or children.

A contented sage shows what it means to be free of this habit. He owned nothing and lived on alms, but he did not feel that anything was missing. Shiva and Parvati visited him while he was mending his clothes. Shiva offered him a boon, or a wish he would grant. The sage could think of nothing to ask for because he already felt he had everything he needed. At Parvati’s insistence, Shiva urged him to choose. The sage looked at his sewing and finally asked that the thread follow his needle. Because he felt fulfilled, he could barely find anything to request.

Charity still needs judgement. Giving without considering the effects can encourage people to depend on gifts. A better test is whether the gift benefits both the recipient and the giver.

In Victor Hugo’s Les Miserables, a priest gives an escaped convict supper and shelter. During the night, the convict steals the household silver plates and leaves. The police catch him and bring him back. The priest says that he gave the plates to the convict, so the police release him. He then gives the man two solid silver candlestick stands as well. He urges him to live by giving rather than taking. The convict leaves astonished and becomes devoted to service and sacrifice. The gift does more than pass wealth from one person to another: it changes the convict’s character.

The donor also benefits from giving. Swami Rama Tirtha says that wealth escapes those who crave it, while rewards come to those who work without attachment to the results. Goldsmith also warns that people can become worse as they strive to accumulate wealth.

The way objects reflect colour gives an analogy for giving. An object that absorbs all seven colours appears black. One that reflects them all appears white. A blue object reflects blue and absorbs the other six colours, so it appears in the colour it gives away. The comparison presents sacrifice, rather than accumulation, as the source of gain.

Charity therefore includes social consciousness: noticing others’ needs and being willing to share and serve. Occasional philanthropy helps people in particular places. But it does not address the wider cause of poverty if selfishness continues throughout society. Families and primary schools should teach concern for others from the beginning. If everyone practised this concern, society would no longer need separate organisations to make up for its absence.

Effects of Manifestation

Goodwill does not mean behaving in the same way towards every being. You may caress a kitten, but you would not handle a serpent that way. Even a spouse may find affection unwelcome if you express it at the wrong time or without considering the circumstances.

A serpent near a village repeatedly attacked and poisoned people. When a sage passed by, it charged towards him. Then it recognised him and begged forgiveness. The sage advised it to give up hatred and cruelty, and it promised to live peacefully.

Days later, the sage returned and found the serpent covered in wounds. After it began showing goodwill to everyone, the villagers had pelted it with stones. The serpent believed it had simply followed his advice. The sage admitted that he had not explained his advice fully. The serpent should have hissed and driven the villagers away without hating them.

The serpent could feel peaceful without leaving itself helpless against attack. The intellect must decide how to express feelings in a way that keeps peace without inviting harm.

Root of Emotion

Emotion grows from thoughts directed towards the world. Ignorance of the Self makes a person feel incomplete. Their thoughts then turn to something outside themselves to fill that gap, just as hunger turns thoughts towards food. This outward movement of thought is desire, kama.

Repeatedly feeding desire makes it grow into greed, lobha. When something blocks desire, thoughts turn against the obstacle as anger, krodha. Tom loves Elizabeth, but John also courts her. Because John stands in the way of Tom’s desire, Tom becomes angry with him. To overcome his anger, Tom must deal with the desire that causes it.

Unchecked desire, greed and anger lead to delusion, moha. People then compare achievements and feel arrogance, mada, towards those below them and envy, matsarya, towards those above them. Once they have something they value, the prospect of losing it brings fear, bhaya. All these emotions begin with the same demand: that the world should make the person feel fulfilled.

The intellect must examine a thought when it first turns towards an object or person. Judging whether to accept or reject that thought stops more thoughts from following unchecked. This matters because desires multiply. Satisfying one often brings several more.

A higher ideal turns attention beyond selfish interests. Concern can grow from oneself to family, community and the world. As a person’s purpose becomes less selfish, their desires become better and fewer. Self-realisation is the ultimate goal, at which desire ends altogether.

Seeking the Self also means giving up the demand that nature follow personal preferences. Here, the biblical teaching about seeking and receiving means seeking the kingdom within, rather than asking for more possessions.

Sabine Baring-Gould’s The Olive Tree tells of two hermits who grow olives for prayer oil. One asks for rain, sunshine and frost in turn. Every request is granted, but his sapling dies. The other leaves his tree in God’s care without specifying the conditions it needs. His tree flourishes and produces abundant olives.

The two trees show the limits of trying to make a larger order follow personal demands. Surrendering the ego means giving up those demands instead of insisting that the world follow one’s chosen plan. Henry David Thoreau’s verse similarly connects leaving work in God’s care with receiving God’s blessing on it.

Desire Veils the Self

Desire can return in a less obvious form. A person may lose interest in wealth but want recognition or fame just as intensely. This resembles exchanging a hundred copper coins for one silver coin. What the person holds has changed, but the attachment remains.

The Self becomes fully revealed only when the selfish ego and every remaining desire disappear. Replacing an obvious ambition with a more refined one does not finish that work.