Chapters

Strength of Emotion

Vedanta teaches how to care for others, give wisely and use judgement to keep emotion and selfish desire from taking over.

On this page

Vedanta aims to strengthen emotion by making it less selfish and more concerned with others. Feelings become a weakness when they overwhelm judgement. They become a strength when the intellect guides people to express them in ways that help others.

Having emotion without surrendering judgement means caring deeply while still thinking about what you should do. Shakespeare’s King Lear, Othello and Macbeth all show how unchecked emotion can cause destruction. Passion, affection and sympathy do not need to disappear, but they must not control decisions.

Oliver Goldsmith’s The Village Preacher shows this balance through an image of a mountain. Clouds gather around a tall cliff, but its peak stays clear above the storm. The clouds stand for feeling, and the peak stands for the intellect. Like the clear peak, the preacher keeps his judgement steady even as he shares love and grief with others.

Arjuna shows what happens when feelings overwhelm judgement. In the Mahabharata, he refuses to fight because his relatives are in the opposing army. Krishna’s teaching in the Bhagavad Gita helps him understand again that he has a duty to defend righteousness. Arjuna then acts with a clearer purpose instead of giving in to overwhelming emotion.

Facets of Emotion

The mind holds many kinds of emotion. Their direction, or whose welfare they concern, determines whether they stay selfish or include others:

  • Self-centred emotion serves only personal interests and is considered impure.
  • Unselfish emotion includes concern for the community and is considered noble.
  • Universal emotion includes concern for the whole universe and is considered divine.

The comparison with a dose of medicine explains why emotion needs limits. Medicine can cure in the right amount, but a concentrated dose of the same substance can harm or kill. Similarly, feeling becomes dangerous when it focuses too strongly on selfish interests. To strengthen emotion, you therefore need to care about more than yourself, rather than simply feel more intensely.

Love

Universal love means treating other beings as parts of one whole, just as you care for every part of your body. Feeling separate from everyone else breaks this sense of belonging together. Becoming attached to one particular person or possession narrows your concern and makes your happiness depend on them or it.

A child shows affection without calculating what they will get in return. But when that child grows into a young man absorbed in his beloved, he may start to see his parents and siblings as burdens. Because his attachment leaves others out, what seems like love can lead to indifference and hostility toward them.

Attachment to possessions creates the same dependence. Wet feet on a treasured carpet cause distress. A dent in a car feels like a personal injury. Parents who cling to their children live with constant worry and anxiety. In all these cases, attachment lets someone or something outside you disturb your peace.

Affection for a partner or child can still be the beginning of wider love. The feeling that starts at home should spread to other beings rather than stop with the family. A spiritual master still carefully fulfils responsibilities to family and society, but also cares about people beyond that private circle.

Kindness and Pity

Kindness and pity affect judgement differently. Compassion helps a person grow spiritually. Pity, however, can make someone give in to another person’s feelings without thinking about what they should do.

  • Kindness means behaving with gentleness and compassion. It is necessary for spiritual growth. Ella Wheeler Wilcox’s verse says that being kind matters more than increasing the number of gods, creeds and religious paths.
  • Pity means sorrow at another person’s suffering. The book treats it as an immature emotion and a human weakness. A person ruled by pity may spend their life trying to please others because disappointing them seems cruel. The intellect must examine their suffering and decide what the situation calls for.

Ahimsa, or non-injury, does not mean refusing every action that causes harm without considering the consequences. Parthasarathy criticises people in India for following this teaching blindly. He argues that doing so left Hindus open to harm from oppressors and invaders. His reading of Shakespeare’s Hamlet also suggests that an act that looks harsh can have a kind purpose.

Arjuna’s situation shows this difference. Refusing to injure his relatives looked compassionate, but Krishna told him to consider the welfare of the whole country. Arjuna needed to judge the purpose and consequences of fighting, rather than simply choose the action that looked gentle.

To judge suffering, you also need to understand its causes and effects. Results follow from causes, not wishes. Pity must not stop you from examining those causes and choosing a suitable response.

Charity

Charity includes giving wealth, service, affection and knowledge. Wanting to receive keeps your attention on what you lack. Giving turns your attention toward what another person needs. Prayer becomes selfish when it consists only of requests for health, wealth, success or children.

A contented sage shows what it means to be free from the need to ask for things. Although he owned nothing and lived on alms, he kept giving and forgiving. Shiva and Parvati visited him while he was mending his torn clothes. Shiva offered to grant him a wish, but the sage could think of nothing he lacked. Parvati insisted that Shiva press him to choose. The sage finally asked only that the thread follow his needle. He was poor, but he still felt fulfilled within himself.

Charity must also benefit the recipient. Giving without considering the result can make someone dependent instead of improving their life. Careful judgement must guide generosity, rather than a brief feeling of sympathy.

Victor Hugo’s Les Miserables gives an example of charity that helps its recipient change. A priest gives an escaped convict supper and shelter. During the night, the convict steals the house’s silver plates. The police catch him and bring him back, but the priest says he gave the plates to him. After the policeman leaves, the priest gives the convict two solid silver candlestick stands as well. He urges him to live by giving rather than taking. This act of charity changes the convict into someone devoted to service and sacrifice.

Giving and Social Consciousness

Giving also changes the person who gives. Swami Rama Tirtha connects sacrifice with success: craving wealth keeps it out of reach, while working without that craving brings its reward. Goldsmith also warns of the harm that comes with selfishly accumulating wealth.

The colour-reflection analogy uses light and colour to explain this teaching. Light contains seven colours. An object that absorbs all seven looks black, while one that reflects them all looks white. A blue object reflects blue and absorbs the other six colours. It therefore looks the colour that it gives away. The comparison suggests that people gain through giving rather than taking.

Social consciousness means noticing other people’s needs and being willing to share, serve and live peacefully with them. It takes charity beyond occasional gifts. Schools should teach children this concern for others, and families should practise it at home.

Social work can ease suffering in particular places without removing the selfishness that keeps poverty going. For change to last, individuals need to learn to care about others. When this concern becomes widespread, separate relief organisations are no longer needed because people already share the world’s available wealth.

Effects of Manifestation

Goodwill needs wise expression. Loving all creatures does not mean treating them all in the same way. You may stroke a kitten, but you would not handle a serpent that way. Even a spouse may find affection unwelcome if you express it without considering when or how to do so.

A serpent near a village repeatedly attacked and poisoned villagers. One day, it charged at a passing sage. It then recognised him as a divine person and begged forgiveness. The sage advised it to stop being hateful and cruel. The serpent repented and promised to live peacefully.

When the sage returned days later, he found the serpent badly wounded. It explained that it had followed his advice, but the villagers had thrown stones at it. The sage admitted that his advice had been incomplete. The serpent should have hissed and driven the villagers away without hating them.

The story shows that living peacefully with others does not mean leaving yourself defenceless. The intellect must decide how to express goodwill in each situation.

Root of Emotion

Emotion begins when thoughts turn toward the world. According to Vedanta, the Self is your true inner nature, which is already complete. Not recognising this makes you feel that something is missing, so you seek fulfilment in the outside world. Your thoughts turn toward objects much as they turn toward food when your stomach is empty. This thought-flow, or stream of thoughts, develops into several related emotions:

  • Kama — desire: Thoughts turn toward an object or being in the hope of feeling fulfilled.
  • Lobha — greed: Repeatedly feeding desire makes the thought-flow stronger.
  • Krodha — anger: Something blocks desire, so thoughts turn against whatever stands in the way.
  • Moha — delusion: Growing desire, greed and anger make it harder to judge clearly.
  • Mada — arrogance: Success leads a person to look down on those they see as less successful.
  • Matsarya — envy: A person resents those they see as more successful.
  • Bhaya — fear: After gaining something, a person becomes afraid of losing it.

Tom’s love for Elizabeth shows how anger depends on desire. Another suitor, John, courts her, which gets in the way of what Tom wants. Tom therefore becomes angry with John. To deal with his anger, he must recognise and remove the desire that caused it.

The intellect should examine a thought as soon as it settles on something. Carefully deciding whether to accept or reject it keeps an unchecked stream of thoughts from becoming a desire. Without this attention, desires change form and multiply. Satisfying one then leads to more demands rather than lasting fulfilment.

Higher Ideals Reduce Desires

A higher ideal turns your concern toward something beyond personal gain. As you move from thinking about yourself to caring about family, community and the world, lower desires become less compelling. Your desires become less selfish, and you have fewer of them. They disappear completely through Self-realisation, which means fully recognising the Self.

The teaching links the Bible’s promise to those who seek and knock with seeking the Self, rather than asking for worldly benefits.

Sabine Baring-Gould’s The Olive Tree shows what happens when people give up personal demands. Two hermits plant olive saplings because they need oil for prayer. One asks for rain, sunshine and frost in turn. God grants each request, yet the plant dies. The other leaves his tree in God’s care without specifying the conditions it needs, and it produces plenty of olives. Their different results show the limits of insisting that nature follow personal wishes. Thoreau’s verse similarly contrasts surrendering to God with trying to take control by making demands.

Desire Veils the Self

To reduce desire, you need to watch for its return in another form. Someone may lose interest in wealth but become absorbed in reputation or fame. They want something different, but they still crave it.

This is like giving up a hundred copper coins to get one silver coin. Replacing an obvious desire with a less obvious one does not free you from desire. The selfish ego and its last remaining desire must disappear before the Self can be fully realised.