Theory of Perception
Vedanta explains perception as thought meeting an object within Brahman, and shows why neither mind nor objects alone can explain the world.
On this page
The senses do not show every being the same world. Ants, elephants and humans perceive it differently. Even one person’s senses give different impressions as conditions change. If the senses tell us what the world really is, whose senses should we trust as the standard?
This problem is like children looking at themselves in convex and concave mirrors. One image stretches tall; another spreads flat. Because the images differ, we have to ask what is really there behind the appearances.
Two theories give opposing answers. Idealism starts with the mind that perceives, while Realism starts with the objects it perceives. Parthasarathy connects branches of Idealism with Berkeley, Plato and Hegel, and Realism with Baine and Mill. These theories are the starting point for Vedanta’s explanation.
Phenomenon of the World
Subject and object are the two sides of an experience: the experiencer and what is experienced. When you look at the countryside, you are the subject and the countryside you see is the object.
In everyday experience, we can treat the mind as the subject because it perceives the world. But the mind itself can also be known and experienced. From the absolute standpoint, which asks what ultimately knows everything experienced, the mind therefore counts as an object. Atman is the true subject that knows the mind.
The theories discussed here take the relative standpoint: they treat the mind as the subject and the world it perceives as the object. We need to keep these standpoints separate so that we do not mistake the perceiving mind for the ultimate Self.
Idealism
In the book’s account, Idealism says that thoughts are real and the perceived world is their illusory projection: thoughts make a world appear real when it is not. It gives two main reasons for this view:
- Perception requires the mind. In deep-sleep, the world disappears from experience. Even while awake, someone absorbed in a novel may miss another person’s presence, voice or pat on the back. This suggests that the senses cannot produce perception unless the mind takes part.
- The senses cannot establish reality. Senses differ between beings and change within one being. Because they change, what they report cannot be an unchanging standard of what the world is.
Hypnotism gives another example of thought shaping experience. A hypnotist tells someone that the floor is a lake. The person sees a lake instead of the floor and begins fishing in it. Idealism treats this as evidence that thought produces the world we perceive.
Vedanta agrees that perception needs the mind, but rejects the claim that the mind alone creates the world. The perceiving subject changes and is itself part of the world that the theory is trying to explain. A dreamer belongs to the dream; that dreamer has not created the dream-world. Likewise, the waker and the waking world belong to the same creation. So one part cannot explain the whole while leaving out the other part.
Realism
In the book’s account, Realism says that objects are real in themselves and exist independently of thought. The sun, hill and brook exist as they appear. Its two main arguments take the opposite view to Idealism:
- Objects remain recognisable. Different people see the same horse, and it remains a horse from day to day. Changes in the mind do not turn it into a mule.
- Thought cannot produce objects at will. If the mind creates everything, it should be able to produce a horse or mule merely by thinking. But thought alone cannot make a substantial object—a physical object rather than just an idea.
Vedanta agrees that perception needs an object, but rejects Realism’s attempt to leave out the subject. Objects also change and belong to the world that the theory is trying to explain. So they cannot explain the whole on their own. Both theories correctly identify something that perception needs. But each goes too far by claiming that this one part is enough.
Vedantic Theory of Perception
The Vedantic Theory of Perception says that subject and object must meet. Neither thought alone nor the object alone produces the world we experience. Perception happens when they interact.
Consider a flower. Its qualities belong to the object, while the matching thought exists in the mind. When the two meet, you perceive the flower. Replace the flower with a stone, and there is no flower to perceive. Leave the flower there but let another thought occupy the mind, and the flower may go unnoticed. Both mind and object must take part.
Brahman supports both sides as their common substratum, the unchanging Reality beneath both. The flower’s qualities change, but that Reality lies beneath them. If those qualities are removed, Brahman remains rather than nothing. The same is true of the mind: that same Reality lies beneath its changing thoughts.
So subject and object do not have two separate foundations. Brahman is present throughout both. Their interaction within Brahman produces the phenomenal world—the world we experience.
The equations for perception
The equations show this relationship. T stands for thought, Q for an object’s quality, and B for Brahman. F indicates flower and P indicates pen.
- Flower: TF + QF + B. The subject side is TF + B, and the object side is QF + B. When they meet, they bring together the thought of the flower, the flower’s quality and their shared Reality.
- Pen: TP + QP + B. The thought of the pen meets the pen’s quality within the same Brahman.
- Phenomenal world: TO1 + TO2 + TO3 etc + QO1 + QO2 + QO3 etc + B. The whole experienced world brings together thoughts of objects, qualities of objects and Brahman.
B appears only once in the combined equations because the Reality beneath subject and object is the same.
Analogies for the meeting of subject and object
Four examples explain how interaction produces appearances while the Reality beneath them remains unchanged:
- Two palms clapping. Neither palm alone produces the clap. The sound comes from the palms striking together. In the same way, perception requires mind and object to meet.
- Positive and negative electrical poles. Neither pole alone produces a spark; contact between them does. Electricity itself contains no spark. In this comparison, the subject is Brahman conditioned by thought, meaning Brahman with thought. The object is Brahman conditioned by quality, meaning Brahman with an object’s quality. When the two meet, they produce the experienced world.
- Ocean and waves. Still water lies beneath the moving surface. Waves collide and produce ripples, bubbles, froth and foam, but all these forms remain water. One wave represents thought and another represents an object’s quality. Their collision represents perception. The water represents Brahman, which remains unchanged through every appearance.
- Cotton, warp and woof. Warp and woof are the two sets of woven threads that form a cloth’s pattern. They represent subject and object, which combine to produce the phenomenal world. Cotton runs through both sets of threads and the entire pattern, just as Brahman is present throughout both sides of experience.
These appearances do not change Brahman. Space gives a final comparison: pot-space and room-space sound separate, but the pot and room do not divide space itself. In the same way, the divisions we experience in the world do not divide Brahman. That undivided Reality is the Self within.
