Chapters

Law of Causation

How past actions shape the present, steady effort changes the future, and Vedanta uses cause and effect to explain its theory of reincarnation.

On this page

The law of causation means that cause and effect keep working throughout nature. A coconut seed produces a coconut tree, which produces more seeds. A chicken produces an egg, and an egg produces a chicken. In each cycle, the result of one cause becomes the cause of something else.

Cause and effect also govern the body, mind and intellect. Physical discipline shapes the body’s condition. Repeated thoughts and feelings shape your personality. What you are now comes from what you did before. What you become depends on what you do from now on.

But cause and effect govern only your material personality: your body, mind and intellect. The supreme Self remains beyond this law. Identifying with the Self instead of the body, mind and intellect therefore frees you from their limitations.

Brahman, the supreme reality, supports the countless laws that hold the universe together. Parthasarathy connects this order with John Milton’s On His Blindness. The poem describes a ruler served by tireless subjects. This image suggests the unseen power behind nature’s work.

Law of Destiny

The law of destiny says that your present personality is the combined result of your past thoughts, desires and actions. What you did before caused your present condition. Education, for example, teaches a person to read and write. Neglecting education leaves a person without that learning.

The same principle applies to spiritual development. Past spiritual discipline brings success and peace in the present. A life spent seeking material and sensual enjoyment brings agitation and sorrow. Repeated sensual indulgence also makes a person more inclined to keep seeking those pleasures.

You cannot undo the past, so the result it has produced in the present is fixed. But this does not mean that an outside power has written your whole future. Vedanta rejects the idea that God’s decrees, stars and planets, luck or accident determine destiny. Your own activity makes your destiny positive or negative.

God makes activity possible without deciding its direction. Petrol allows a car to move, but the engine determines its power and the driver chooses where it goes. Likewise, God makes thought, desire and action possible. The mind and intellect determine what those thoughts, desires and actions are like and where they lead. God does not make people’s virtuous or vicious choices.

Parthasarathy uses Richard Chenevix Trench’s image of a stone finding its place in a wall because it is suitable for that wall. The image shows how a person’s fitness for something affects what happens to them. Fortune follows what a person has made himself fit to receive, rather than what he merely wishes for.

Law of Karma

The law of karma applies the law of destiny to the future. Past activity has made you what you are, but you can also act now to create new causes. Looking only at the past can leave you discouraged by your shortcomings. Looking ahead shows that you have a chance to change them. Two forces meet in every action:

  • Prarabdha: Past efforts have built up tendencies and shaped your present condition. These continue to influence you now.
  • Purushartha: Your effort in the present gives you the freedom to choose what to do. Once you act, those efforts help shape your later destiny.

A bank balance shows how the two work together. The balance records all earlier credits and debits. But whether your account is positive or negative, you can still earn, spend or lose money. The existing balance does not take away that ability. Similarly, whatever your present spiritual condition, you can still make efforts that improve or worsen it.

God’s support does not take away this responsibility. The sun gives vitality to both sinner and saint. But they act differently because their natures differ. Neither person’s conduct makes the sun virtuous or vicious. Likewise, God makes it possible for both to act without deciding their choices.

How Persistent Effort Changes Destiny

Established tendencies resist change, but they do not decide every choice you make now. If they did, good people could never turn bad, and bad people could never become good.

A motorboat travels at 16 kilometres per hour in still water. In a current flowing at 2 kilometres per hour, it travels downstream at 18 kilometres per hour and upstream at 14. The boat’s own speed remains 16, but the current changes its speed over the ground. Purushartha is like the boat’s own drive. Prarabdha is like the current, which affects the result of that effort.

An alcoholic may choose not to drink but still drink because the established tendency is stronger than that effort. Continued efforts to abstain can gradually weaken the tendency. One unsuccessful attempt does not prove that the person has no choice.

Persistent effort changes the combined result over time. If you apply blue paint to a yellow wall, it initially looks green. The blue paint is there, but the old colour still affects what you see. Keep applying blue paint and the wall eventually becomes blue. In the same way, present effort must work against established tendencies. Repeating the effort in the same direction gradually changes those tendencies.

Birth and Death

Birth and death are changes of state as life continues. Morning disappears as evening arrives, and evening gives way to night. Seasons appear and disappear while the year continues. These examples show how creation, destruction and maintenance belong to one continuing process. The scriptures represent these related powers as gods:

  • Brahma: Represents creation.
  • Shiva: Represents destruction.
  • Vishnu: Represents maintenance.

Dattatreya combines the three gods to show that these powers cannot be separated.

Simply saying that life ends at death, or that it continues, does not settle the question. The same is true of beliefs about heaven and hell. To understand, you must examine the available evidence and reason from it.

People know that they will die, yet often live as though death remains far away. They keep accumulating possessions and relationships even in old age. The book explains this apparent contradiction through the immortal Self. Its lasting nature gives the material personality a borrowed feeling that it, too, will last.

Theory of Reincarnation

The theory of reincarnation links desires that remain at death with tendencies that appear at birth. During life, desires already lead a person from one experience to another. Death does not itself use up those desires, so Vedanta reasons that they must continue to have effects.

Parthasarathy applies the conservation of matter and energy to the subtle body, which consists of the mind and intellect. According to this reasoning, mental and intellectual energies cannot suddenly vanish at death or appear from nothing at birth. The sages therefore linked the desires that seem to disappear at death with those that appear at birth, treating them as causes and effects.

Reincarnation is presented as a conclusion drawn from this account of cause and effect, not an experimentally proved fact. The book explicitly calls it a theory.

Within the theory, the accumulated mental and intellectual forces find a suitable body, parents and environment. The theory does not reject heredity, but it explains the relationship differently. The incoming individual’s nature leads them to compatible parents, rather than the parents alone determining that nature.

This raises a difficulty. Why would someone who wants wealth be born poor, or someone who wants sight be born blind? A single wish does not decide what happens. All desires act together, so their combined effect may differ from any one wish.

Resultant Desire

Resultant desire is the combined effect of desires that differ in strength and direction. The parallelogram of forces shows how this works. Two equal forces act on an object at O. One pushes it horizontally toward A, and the other pushes it vertically toward B. Because both forces act together, the object moves diagonally along OR, rather than in either force’s direction. Adding more forces produces a different combined direction, OR’. Likewise, a person’s life need not follow any particular wish because all their desires together determine its course.

An elderly woman developed cataracts and then lost her only daughter. In her grief, she refused surgery because she felt there was nothing left worth seeing. Her family asked a swami for help. He warned that her strong wish not to see could help bring about a future birth without sight. She underwent surgery that same day. Parthasarathy uses this story to urge people to examine negative desires within the theory, rather than assume that each wish is harmless.

Another example imagines someone whose persistent desire to kill cannot be acted on under human law. The theory allows that such desires could lead to birth in an animal body, such as a tiger or lion. Human emotions and subtler thoughts ordinarily favour human birth. A change to an animal body would therefore require a persistent destructive passion.

The book separately suggests that there may be a delay between death and rebirth, but presents this as a conjecture. Seeds do not always germinate immediately, and eggs take time to hatch. By comparison, it proposes an interval resembling sleep or dream.

The Mirror Transferred Between Frames

In the proposed transfer between lives, the subtle and causal bodies move, while the gross body, the physical body, remains behind. The causal body holds the underlying impressions called vasanas. Atman, the Self, does not travel because it is already everywhere. To move, it would need to go somewhere it had previously been absent.

A mirror in a frame reflects the sun. If you move the mirror into another frame, the reflection disappears from the first and appears in the second. The sun itself has not moved between the frames.

The sun represents Atman, and its rays represent pure Consciousness. The frames represent gross bodies. The mirror’s glass represents the subtle body, while its reflecting material represents the causal body. Moving the mirror shows the transfer that the theory calls death in one body and birth in another.

This cycle continues while vasanas and desires remain. When they are used up, the subtle and causal bodies no longer keep a person a separate individual. The cycle ends in Self-realisation, the recognition of oneself as the Self. Throughout this teaching, the practical task is to examine thoughts, desires and actions, because present effort creates the causes of what happens next.