Law of Causation

How past activity shapes destiny, present effort changes the future, and Vedanta extends cause and effect into a theory of reincarnation.

The Supreme Law

The law of causation is the continuous working of cause and effect throughout nature. A coconut seed produces a coconut tree, which produces more seeds. A chicken produces an egg, and an egg produces a chicken. The world consists of such connected changes.

Brahman holds these laws together without being subject to them. John Milton’s On His Blindness supplies the image of a sovereign whose servants work ceaselessly across land and sea. It suggests how countless laws operate under one unseen power.

Cause and effect govern human personalities too. Physical training shapes the body. Thoughts, feelings and actions shape the mind and intellect. Your present condition therefore carries the effects of past activity, while what you do now helps determine your future condition.

But this law does not govern the supreme Self. It affects the body, mind and intellect, not the Atman that enlivens them. Spiritual liberation requires recognising that your real identity is the Self, which is beyond cause and effect, rather than your changing body, mind and intellect.

Law of Destiny

The law of destiny describes your present condition as the cumulative effect of your past thoughts, desires and actions. Past activity is the cause; your present personality is the effect. Earlier education, for example, determines whether you are literate now.

Your present destiny is fixed in this limited sense: you cannot undo actions already completed or erase the condition they have produced. This does not mean that an outside power has written your entire future. Destiny is neither a divine decree nor the work of stars, luck or accident.

God enables activity but does not choose its character. The petrol, engine and driver analogy makes this distinction clear. Petrol makes a car’s movement possible. The engine determines its performance, and the driver determines its direction. Likewise, God enables thought, desire and action, while the mind and intellect determine their quality and course.

This separates the source of activity from responsibility for its use. God does not author virtuous or vicious choices. Their character comes from the person making them.

Positive thought, feeling and action create favourable causes; negative activity creates unfavourable ones. Richard Chenevix Trench’s image of a suitable stone finding its place in a wall expresses this connection between fitness and outcome. What matters is what your activity has prepared you to receive, rather than what you merely wish to receive.

Law of Karma

The law of karma extends the law of destiny into the future. Destiny explains how the past has produced you. Karma adds that your present activity produces what you will become. You occupy both positions at once, just as someone can be a son to his father and a father to his son.

You cannot undo the past that has shaped your present condition, but you can introduce new causes through present self-effort. Established tendencies affect the outcome without removing the possibility of change.

Two forces meet in every choice. Prarabdha is the momentum left by past self-effort. Purushartha is the present self-effort through which you choose a course of action. Once an effort has been made, its effects become part of the background against which later choices occur.

Destiny resembles a bank balance. The balance at any moment records all earlier credits and debits. It does not remove your capacity to earn more or spend more. Likewise, your present condition does not prevent effort that improves or worsens your future condition.

Success and failure therefore cannot simply be attributed to God. The sun gives vitality to both sinner and saint without taking blame or credit for their deeds. In the same way, God supports activity without determining whether a person acts virtuously or viciously.

Yet established tendencies resist change. A person accustomed to sensual indulgence tends to continue it; someone accustomed to discipline tends to remain disciplined. If the past completely controlled present action, neither could change. But good people can turn bad, and bad people can turn good.

The motorboat-and-current analogy explains how freedom and resistance coexist. A motorboat travels at 16 kilometres per hour in still water. In a river flowing at 2 kilometres per hour, it travels downstream at 18 and upstream at 14. Its own speed remains 16, but the current changes its progress over the ground.

The boat’s independent movement represents purushartha; the current represents prarabdha. Present effort makes a choice, but the outcome reflects both that effort and the background against which it works.

An alcoholic may decide not to drink and still drink because the established tendency outweighs the effort to abstain. Repeatedly exercising the choice not to drink can gradually counter that tendency. An unsuccessful attempt therefore does not establish that self-effort is absent or useless.

Blue paint on a yellow wall shows why persistence matters. The first application appears green because the new blue meets the existing yellow. Continued applications eventually make the wall blue. The paint in the hand represents free self-effort; the yellow wall represents destiny. Early results reflect both, but sustained effort changes the background itself.

Birth and Death

Birth and death are changes of state within a continuous sequence. Morning passes into evening, evening into night, and night into morning. The seasons likewise appear and disappear while the year continues. Creation, destruction and maintenance are three aspects of this same process.

The scriptures personify these powers as Brahma for creation, Shiva for destruction and Vishnu for maintenance. Dattatreya combines the three to indicate that they belong to one phenomenon rather than three unrelated processes.

Assertions that death ends everything, that life necessarily continues, or that people enter imagined heavens and hells do not settle the question. Understanding requires examining the relevant experience rather than accepting a belief without reasoning.

People also behave inconsistently towards death. They know it is inevitable, yet continue accumulating possessions and relationships as though it were distant. Parthasarathy attributes this felt assurance of continued existence to the immortal Self, whose nature colours the individual’s sense of identity.

Theory of Reincarnation

The theory of reincarnation extends the causal account beyond one lifetime. Desires drive the succession of experiences during life. Since many remain unfulfilled at death, the theory treats them as causes whose effects have not yet finished appearing.

Parthasarathy applies the conservation of matter and energy to the subtle body. He reasons that thoughts, feelings and desires cannot simply vanish when the physical body dies. He then connects the unfulfilled desires of the dead with the distinct tendencies appearing in newborn people.

This is presented as a deduction from cause and effect, not as an experimentally proved account. The theory proposes that continuing mental and intellectual energies find another body and environment through which to express themselves.

It does not reject heredity, but reverses the assumed direction of the connection. The continuing individual’s tendencies determine the parents, body and circumstances suited to their expression. No outside power makes that selection.

This raises an objection: why would anyone enter circumstances they do not want? The answer rests on resultant desire—the combined effect of all desires, rather than any single wish.

The parallelogram of forces illustrates this. Two equal forces act on an object at right angles, one horizontally and one vertically. The object moves diagonally, in the direction of their combined force, although neither individual force points that way. Add more forces of different strengths and directions, and their resultant may differ from every one of them.

Likewise, the theory makes the whole combination of desires responsible for a future embodiment. A particular wish for wealth or health does not by itself determine the result.

At death, the gross body remains and its material returns to earth. Atman does not travel because it already pervades everywhere. The theory describes death and rebirth as the transfer of the subtle and causal bodies from one gross body to another.

A mirror transferred between frames supplies the analogy. In sunlight, a mirror produces a reflected sun within its frame. Move the mirror to another frame, and the reflection disappears from the first and appears in the second. The sun represents Atman, its rays pure Consciousness, and the frames gross bodies. The mirror’s glass and reflecting material represent the subtle and causal bodies. The transfer changes where the individual appears without moving the all-pervading Self.

An elderly woman’s cataracts provide a story about resultant desire. After her only daughter died, she lost interest in the world and refused surgery, even as she became practically blind. Her family sought a swami’s help. He warned that her strong desire not to see could contribute to a future birth without sight. She underwent surgery that same day. Within the theory, the story illustrates how an outcome could follow from a desire without being consciously wished for in that form.

A further example concerns someone persistently drawn to killing. If human society prevents those desires from finding expression, their combined force could lead to an animal embodiment such as a tiger or lion. Human emotions and subtle thoughts normally weigh towards another human birth, so such a change is presented as difficult, not automatic.

The possibility of a delay between incarnations remains a conjecture. The intervening experience might resemble sleep or dream, just as a fallen seed need not germinate immediately and an egg takes time to hatch.

In this account, the cycle continues while vasanas and desires remain. Their complete exhaustion ends the causes of further embodiment and brings Self-realisation. Responsibility therefore lies in examining and changing the desires being cultivated, rather than blaming stars, planets or God for their consequences.