Use and Abuse of Religion
Religion helps people grow spiritually when practices fit their needs, reduce desires, and lead beyond brief relief or attachment to the practices.
On this page
Religion helps the individual develop, just as science helps improve the world. Life involves both the person and the world around them, so both need attention. Better outward conditions alone cannot prepare someone to face life peacefully.
Spiritual development takes organised training, guidance and personal effort. Reading whichever medical books interest you does not make you a surgeon. Similarly, collecting rituals, prayers and religious information without a planned course does not make you spiritually mature.
Individual Diagnosis and Treatment
Diagnosis comes before spiritual treatment. First, assess the relative strength of your mind, which feels emotions, and your intellect, which thinks and judges. This helps you decide which discipline best fits your needs:
- Emotional: When the mind is stronger, the Path of Devotion directs feelings towards spiritual growth.
- Intellectual: When the intellect is stronger, the Path of Knowledge builds understanding through questioning and reflection.
- Active: When mind and intellect are balanced, the Path of Action uses both in work for a higher ideal.
Choose a discipline that fits svadharma, your own inner nature. Avoid training based on paradharma, a nature different from your own. The same principle applies to a career. Someone drawn to mathematics should pursue it rather than a field that does not suit them. Birth, family custom and opportunity do not prove that a religious practice meets your needs.
Nobody belongs entirely to one category. The seventy–ten–twenty discipline example shows how to divide your practice: someone who is 70% intellectual, 10% emotional and 20% active should give 70% of their time and effort to Knowledge, 10% to Devotion and 20% to Action. Both the kind and the amount of practice matter, just as medicine requires the right dose. The programme must also match what the person can manage.
Meditation comes at the end of this preparation. A restless mind weighed down by desires is like an overloaded aircraft trying to take off. The load keeps the aircraft from rising and puts it at risk of crashing. The comparison warns you to reduce desires through suitable disciplines before attempting meditation.
Positive Religion
Positive religion means using religion to reduce desires and move towards union with the Self, your true spiritual nature. The three disciplines help in different ways:
- Bhakti Yoga improves quality: This practice directs feelings towards divinity. Devotion gradually replaces thoughts absorbed in worldly affairs, so worldly desires have less hold over the person.
- Gnana Yoga changes direction: This practice uses the intellect to keep the mind focused on the Eternal, the unchanging spiritual reality, while dealing with the changing world. Many different worldly thoughts give way to the thought of the Self.
- Karma Yoga reduces bulk: This practice directs work towards an ideal beyond personal gain. Because mind and intellect focus on that ideal, the person stops feeding selfish thoughts and desires.
As the person develops, they can aim towards Self-realisation, or recognising the Self. Regular practice gradually reduces desires and brings the mind into balance. This prepares the mind for meditation focused on one thought.
In Parthasarathy’s reading of Bhagavad Gita IX.22, Lord Krishna promises spiritual progress and Enlightenment to those who keep their attention on the Self. The emphasis is on continued awareness, rather than an occasional religious act.
Keeping Awareness of the Self During Activity
Everyday activity need not interrupt awareness of the Self. The body can carry out its duties, and the mind can feel emotions. The gross-intellect, which deals with worldly matters, can handle everyday thoughts. Meanwhile, the subtle-intellect, which considers spiritual matters, keeps its attention on the Self.
Indian classical music gives an example. During a concert, a background note called shruti sounds continuously. The musician performs different songs, tunes and beats while keeping some attention on that unchanging note. A trained musician depends on it, although a layperson might find it distracting while singing.
The same kind of attention is possible in daily life. Perceptions, emotions and thoughts change, but a person can remain aware of the unchanging Consciousness that makes these experiences possible. They do not need to stop their other activities. They need to learn to attend to the Self while carrying them out, just as the musician keeps listening to the background note throughout the performance.
Negative Religion
Negative religion means using religious practices only to get what you personally want. The person seeks worldly benefits, with no intention of reducing desires or discovering the Self. This takes three broad forms:
- Material gain: People use pilgrimages, ceremonies and prayers to seek wealth, status, health or other outward benefits.
- Emotional solace: A distressed person turns to religion to ease suffering, but seeks nothing beyond that relief.
- Intellectual curiosity: Someone reads religious literature to answer questions about the world, then stops when those questions are answered.
These motives leave the person’s feelings, desires and thinking largely unchanged. Spiritual education instead develops purer emotions, independent thinking and a stronger intellect. It turns the person’s attention inward towards the Reality, the spiritual truth they seek.
This education takes continued effort, and results come gradually. People who want an immediate remedy are therefore more likely to accept practices that promise relief without this preparation.
Physical Exercises and Inner Education
Parthasarathy criticises treating yoga as nothing more than physical postures and breathing exercises. Asanas, or physical postures, and pranayama, or breathing exercises, can improve the body. But physical training alone does not develop the mind and intellect. The gross body, the physical body, cannot control the subtle body, the mind and intellect.
This distinction does not deny that exercise has value. It means that exercise alone is not spiritual education. A person can train their body while leaving their desires and reasoning unchanged.
Both physical exercises and meditation are easy for teachers to explain and for followers to begin. This helps explain their popularity. But publicity, family habit and peer pressure cannot replace an assessment of individual needs or a planned course of spiritual development.
Why Temporary Solace Is Not Transformation
The criticism of meditation offered without assessing individual needs concerns unprepared minds, rather than meditation undertaken properly. Parthasarathy compares religious heads selling meditation to sellers of Swiss watches and Japanese cars. Meditation has become a multimillion-dollar business. Buyers attracted by publicity do not understand what they are buying or how it might affect minds crowded with desires.
Focusing a distressed mind on one thought can bring immediate peace. For those moments, the person stops thinking about their many worries. But this relief does not prove that the desires causing the distress have gone. When the first effect fades, unprepared practitioners can lose their mental balance and become increasingly agitated and frustrated. Some assume they need to try harder, so they do more of the same mistaken practice and cause themselves greater harm.
A businessman’s woodland picnic shows how brief relief differs from lasting change. He spends sleepless nights in his luxurious mansion. On a rare outing, his wife prepares a meal while the children chase butterflies. He rests his head on a tree root sticking out of the ground and falls asleep. Yet he could not sleep on his cushioned mattress in an air-conditioned bedroom.
The woodland surroundings briefly calm his troubled mind. But repeated visits stop having that effect. He may then become more restless because he misses the comforts of home. The setting has given him brief relief without changing his inner nature.
Subduing Desires Does Not Remove Them
A snake numbed by cold shows why people can mistake temporary inactivity for lasting change. In a Himalayan winter, a coiled snake can look lifeless and be handled like a rope. A little warmth makes it move again. Although it seemed lifeless, its nature had not changed.
Similarly, religious practices may briefly quiet the ego, the sense of a separate self, and desire. Both can return when circumstances allow them to act again. Returning stress and strain show the difference between brief relief and spiritual development. The disciplines must remove desires rather than merely keep them inactive for a while.
Impediments in the Spiritual Path
Attachment can hold back development even when a seeker follows a suitable course. It takes two forms, both of which draw attention away from the goal:
- Attachment to worldly experience: Craving sensual pleasure, emotional feeling and intellectual ideas keeps a person’s attention on worldly affairs. They forget the spiritual goal.
- Attachment to spiritual practice: Devotion, Knowledge and Action can become so enjoyable that the seeker practises for pleasure rather than Enlightenment. Enjoyment replaces the original purpose.
The second attachment can be harder to overcome because spiritual practices offer greater peace and joy than ordinary pursuits. This makes the seeker more reluctant to let go of them. Parthasarathy reads Isavasya Upanishad, verse 9 as a warning that attachment to spiritual courses can leave a person in greater ignorance than attachment to material life.
Daily Vedantic study and reflection strengthen the intellect. This helps the person judge both worldly and spiritual activities without being carried away by their enjoyment. The disciplines must help the seeker reach the goal without becoming things the seeker clings to.
The pole-vault comparison explains why the seeker must eventually leave the disciplines behind. An athlete runs with a pole, plants one end in the ground and uses it to rise towards the bar. At the required height, the athlete lets go of the pole and crosses over. Without the pole, the athlete could not reach that height. But holding on to it after that point would knock the bar down.
Spiritual courses likewise give the seeker the preparation they need, but they remain within the terrestrial realm, or worldly existence. They bring the seeker to the highest development possible there, but not directly to the Transcendental, which lies beyond worldly existence. At that point, the seeker must stop clinging to the courses. Now prepared, the seeker enters the silence of meditation and passes beyond the practices that helped them reach it.
